Bethlehem Dairy Store

I was in the mood for ice cream then searched on Google maps and found Bethlehem Dairy Store. The reviews were good so I stopped and ordered a banana split. It was not disappointing at all ! Delicious flavor & generous serving, server was nice and received my order quickly. I would visit again when in the area for work.

Wow! My experience with this cream eatery was great. I bought a few things just to see the quality of different options and each one was better than the last. First, The Waffle Ice Cream sandwich. The was was toasted and I got hard vanilla and it was spectacular. Warm and crispy with an ice cream center. Amazing. Second was the milk shake, I got a Thick Black and White and again it was perfect. The quality and portion of ice cream was very generous and was not able to eat everything by myself. But my experience at Th Bethlehem Dairy Store was a good one. Great atmosphere and customer service was five stars alone. The environment was very relaxed and welcoming, so if you ever get a craving for ice cream, make sure you check out this spot, I know you'll enjoy my it

This is a great place to get ice cream. The first thing that caught my eye was the retro atmosphere with checkerboard floors and neon signs. The staff was also kind enough to suggest some of their home made flavors. Since I love ice cream cake, Justin served a soft serve vanilla with the crumble on top! I enjoyed my ice cream but even better in their outdoor seating they have available in the summer. I recommend going here if you’re ever in the area!

The ice cream is pretty good, but the policies aren't. They made my 87 year old grandmother wait outside in the 100 degree heat. Kicked her out when she said she was having heat stroke while other people got to eat inside. Nobody has a mask, but they said it was for covid. Definitely wouldn't recommend this place until they value humans over their selective policies.

Very good ice cream at The Cup Bethlehem Dairy Store. We loved everything about this location including the nostalgic interior checkered floors with neon signs! The staff was very friendly with quick service. We had the Moose Track shake, the lemon Italian ice and vanilla ice cream. All were very very good! Would highly recommend this location which has been in the area for over 90 years!