Purtouliano's Pizza And More

I used to live in the neighborhood and ordered from here all the time. Well, now I moved to Brooklyn and no other pizza shop can really compare to John & Joes. Came back here after a few years and everything tasted exactly the same. I almost cried. The portions, the prices and the quality is everything I remember and better.

9/27/23, Large (18 in) Pepperoni Pizza Listed as 19.95 on the board, turned out to be 20.80, tax was 1.82, total was 22.62. Turned out great. They said it'd be ready in 15-20m, and they were right. Came back from a walk around 18m later and paid then, ate my first slice around 25m after ordering. Note: Have scissors or a sharp blade on hand to cut the string tying the box closed. The pizza actually filled out the whole box from side to side. Crust was excellent, cheese isn't the stretchy stuff, pepperoni tasted great, some grease/oil as well (probably from the pepperoni). 18 inches is huge. For me, it makes for 4 meals over 4 days. Reacted like Vincent from Pulp Fiction when I opened that box, with steaming ready pizza. "We happy." 10/10 would eat again.

I've been coming here since my mother carried me up Lydig Ave as a baby. The food is exactly the same for the 40 years I have been eating it. Staff is friendly. I brought my family here on Saturday and it was just as amazing as the 1st time. Angelo, you are missing the 1993 baseball sponsor plaque. Give me some time, but you will have it soon.