Milk Bar Williamsburg

I recently visited The Milk Bar dessert shop, and let me tell you, it was an udderly hilarious experience! As I walked in, I couldn't help but notice the staff members mysteriously disappearing into the back. Little did I know, they were actually milking cows! It turns out, The Milk Bar takes their name quite literally. But hey, who needs professional bakers when you have a team of talented cow milkers, right? Despite the unconventional staffing choices, the desserts were surprisingly delicious. The milkshakes had that authentic farm-fresh taste, and they were so creamy it could give the cows themselves a run for their money. The ambiance was definitely unique, with the occasional "moo" echoing through the shop and the smell of hay subtly wafting in the air. It felt like a bizarre blend of dessert shop and barnyard, but somehow it worked. Just be prepared for the occasional cow-themed decor and the occasional appearance of a straw hat-wearing staff member with milk-stained overalls. All in all, if you're looking for a dessert experience that's utterly unforgettable, make your way to The Milk Bar and prepare to be entertained, amused, and maybe even milked for laughs!

We learned about Milk Bar through the Netflix series. The lady who had the idea of creating cereal flavored ice cream deserves a medal! Like seriously. This stuff is addicting and crazily delicious. Yes, it is a tad bit expensive but absolutely worth it. The cookies are very nice as well even though some were a bit too sugary to my tastes.

A fun spot and great to cross off the Places To Eat list while in NY. We went near to close and our slice of bday cake was still moist and seemed fresh. It's of course a little pricey but it's still worth the visit. The milk bar pie was super sweet but delicious. The soft serve with corn flakes was bomb. The girl at the window was so sweet and helpful. I enjoyed the entire visit.

I came for the cereal milk ice cream and it was delicious! I decided to try the crack pie and it was just ok, it's reputation gave me the sense that I would have to buy 2 more after eating one. It wasn't the case. I did also try the birthday truffles and they were good but not something I would come back for specifically. I'm sticking with the ice cream when I come back!

From upstate NY to New Mexico and back Milk Bar was my final and most anticipated destination this trip. It didn't disappoint but it didn't necessarily live up to my expectations. The cookies and crack pie are pre-packaged?? But at least they warm the cookie up. Crack pie was more like straight up sugar pie without distinguishable variety in texture or flavor between the crust and the rest of the pie. (I did eat the whole thing in practically one bite though.) Not as good as its reputation precedes but worth a try.