Sicely's Best Pizzeria & Restaurant

This place is a hidden gem. The service is excellent and the pizza is amazing! Reminds me of the pizza I grew up on in Brooklyn during the late 70's and 80's. Caspar is a cool guy and serves up some great tasting food. If you are in the neighborhood and want some really good Italian food check this place out.

If we could give more stars we would! What a great experience and the best authentic pizza! My family of 6 came in around 8p for some Brooklyn pizza last night and we found it! Food was hot and ready, he was able to make my gluten free pizza. We had no complaints from the kiddos which is rare thing. The owner was pleasant, funny, down to earth and just pretty awesome! We had great conversations and talked about places to go around. Thanks for great food and a great memory! Oh the cannolis were super yummy as well!!

MY GO TO CHOICE FOR A SAFE AND DELICIOUS MEAL! It's day 16 of my wife and I being locked in and it was time to treat ourselves. I've had Sicily's Best a few times and loved it but of course I was nervous to get take out. It seems like Russian roulette out there with business that either take this health crisis seriously or don't. Well, this will be our go to treat now during these weird times. The door was propped open so I didn't need to touch it and the owner was making pies with a mask on his face and sanitizing his hands regularly. He offered me a squirt of sanitizer for myself and told me that he's overpaying for it, but he wants to keep his workers clean and healthy too. I watched as he pulled my pizza straight out of the oven and into a box with no other contact. The pie was as delicious as always. It was supposed to last until lunch the next day but it didn't make it past the night.

Was recommended this place by a woman my girlfriend and I now refer to as Aunt Christina (aka Maria) while we were visiting Charleston, SC. We have never been to Ridgewood before but this was a worthwhile little trip. Gaspar was awesome and super friendly. All the food was great and fresh. Left full and happy. A surprise recommendation that turned out great, glad we stopped by.