Billy Sunday

Drinks are very good and the menu is fun to peruse. You can't go wrong with anything. That said - for me, the service doesn't match the ambience. The room smelled stale and funky. Bartenders were extra casual - cutoff jeans and tank casual - and this doesn't match the decor or the quality of the drinks. Maybe not that big of deal to most, but Billy Sunday isn't coherent. Our bartender couldn't remember the happy hour specials and didn't offer to locate them. The app we ordered was missing part of what the menu stated and server brought it quickly when we asked. I'd expect this sort of 'help yourself' quality at a dive bar - but this isn't a dive bar. Or at least, I didn't think it was.

Stopped in here for a quick drink with a friend who drinks spirit-free only. I was incredibly impressed with my vintage amaro daiquiri (coming complete with bottle and quick 101 on how to date it), but even more impressed with the care put into their non-alcoholic beverages to still be well-crafted cocktail experiences. Will definitely be back soon!

Ordered a cocktail and a cheese plate. Everything was great but I'd make a few tweaks to the menus. Too many of the cocktails contained an amaro component, a couple more crushable cocktails would make more sense, especially for summertime. The cheese plate was delicious but it could have a soft cheese en lieu of two hard salty ones. There could be seasoned nuts in place of two dried fruits as well. The bread and cracker bowl was a pleasant surprise. Quite a few couples from what it looks like. Cool varied playlist, never knew what I was going to expect. Service was attentive and warm, good job you guys!

I stopped in after getting less than stellar reception at a location around the corner. I let the host know I had limited time for a quick drink, as I was headed to a show. She was friendly, welcoming and I was handed a menu as soon as I sat down (not the case at the other place, which shall remain nameless). She introduced herself, gave me time to look over the menu. When I asked for bartender's choice of the Amaros (my reason for going to Billy Sunday: their fantastic Amaro selection and bartender knowledge), she asked a few questions about preferences and poured me a glass that did not disappoint. I also had a non-alcoholic drink, which was nicely flavored and very refreshing. Great prompt friendly and un-stuffy service. It's always a pleasure.