Hathaway's Diner

A quaint diner located in a line of other businesses, a real gem worth taking the time to discover! I just had a lunch there today, ambiance was lively, and you can tell this is the place the locals are proud to call their own! I was definitely the new kid on the block as this was my first visit. Most definitely this won’t be my last visit. Food portions were generous and presentation was good! Staff were attentive, and courteous! They take Covid restrictions seriously and are always cleaning up the place. The only recommendation I have is when serving the beef dip or Philly steak, ask if the bread should be served grilled on the side. I found my sandwich to be soggy on arrival, I can’t stand soggy bread on a sandwich, it’s ironic knowing that I’ll dip that same sandwich in sauce, hence beef dip! My opinion I think when plated the bread shouldn’t be soggy!This place chefs up breakfast all day and lunch till 4pm. I don’t see that their open for dinner, unsure if this is due to Covid or if it’s always been this way. Parking is tight and parking lot today was super Icy, so be careful and don’t slip and fall. My belly was full and I had my jacket on and I had even paid the bill. The kind waitress looked at me and said this is your first time here, you can’t leave without trying the pie, I’ll give you a piece on the house. So what did I do, I took off my jacket and ate some pie. I have never in my life ate pineapple pistachio pie and let me tell you, it was the best pie I’ve ever had!! Don’t let this gem be left, take the time to check it out, you won’t be disappointed!

Always good food and great options. Every time I come here I have a great experience, the food is on point and service is great. However this time something was off. Not sure what happened… my wife ordered the eggs Benedict with the sauce on the side, I order the steak and eggs. We also order an order of French toast which we said we like to have after our meal. Guess what? My wife got her meal not the way she asked, my order was good and guess what… we got the French toast at the same time. So we had very cold French toast for dessert which we did not want. This wreck the experience completely. Don’t get me wrong the food was great, but was disappointed with the level of attention and service from our waitress. Time to pay.. which took forever to get around to. As always I tip well, I feel everyone deserved a good tip. When it was all set and done our waitress didn’t even say “thank you or see you again” which I thought it was insane. Just walked away and moved to the next person. Anyways.. maybe it was an off day and hopefully my next visit is better. I do like this place and I hope the take my constructive criticism well and not be mad at me for being harsh. Kept on eating and have fun. #chicosreviews76

Enjoyed every moment while I was there, somewhat wished the breakfast came with a bit more toast instead of choosing to have French toast with it instead of toast and hash browns with steak and eggs.. I would have paid more but I misread the menu, I’m a beast though. Still loved it, outstanding service and owner was definitely there to put in the extra work. Love it.

I love diners! If you love heading out for breakfast with loved ones then this is a diner that won’t disappoint. Everyone was inviting and the food was amazing. I wish I had room for one of the delicious looking pies they had on display but I will save that for the next time. I can’t wait to eat here again!

Highly recommend!!!! Came here for our companys friday lunch and was the best choice my boss made. We all were extremely happy with our meals, was incredibly delicious. Friendly staff and such a neat little place! I ordered the Rueben Sandwhich with Poutine and Coconut Cream pie, not one bad comment on any of it. I will definitely be stopping by there again.