Sundays On The Bay

The food and drinks in this place was amazing Great kids menu and amazing atmosphere Really enjoyed my time at this establishment Very clean and excellent staff. I had to go on a Sunday and it was great Clam chowder was very delicious and the oysters super fresh and tasty My scallop risotto was amazing maybe the best I ever had. Definitely coming back on my next Long Island trip.

Wonderful place! The location was perfect (weather helped out), service was prompt and friendly, and the food was amazing. All around great! Started off with the Oysters (cooked), got the Fish Tacos...Fish Sandwich and Lobster Roll. Lobster Roll was mine and delicious! Totally worth the price. The view helped as well, and we were in and out pretty quickly. Highly recommend stopping by if in the area.

Off season here can be very chill. It's generally pretty easy to get a table once the tourists have gone home and the food is definitely worth the trip to the bay. We ordered clams and oysters on the half shell and both were awesome! Very fresh, very tasty, and served ice cold. Honestly some of the best oysters I've had! My dinner was the kale salad and it did not disappoint. It was full of wonderful fresh ingredients and the kale was expertly prepared and dressed just the right amount. Overall it was a pretty good experience and I will go back!

At around $50/head+ for two courses and drinks this is a pricey eat but mostly hits the target. You basically have only two choices if you want to eat in comfort around Ponquogue dunes: this place and the neighboring hotel. Both are very busy so call ahead for everything from reservations to parking. The food is fresh, cooked well, and served with courtesy and timeliness. The lobster roll had way too much mayo. Their baked clams are a hit in reviews and do have an attractive smoky quality. The fish tacos need more fish but were packed with tasty fresh trimmings. The restaurant is very clean; bathrooms can get busy. The Bar selection is complete.

I had the lobster salad while my friend had the lobster roll. Hers was a little bland while mine was quite tasty with the mangoes and cashews on it. It was a little chilly with the wind outside but a beautiful day to get some fresh air. The view of the docks as well as the fishing boats coming in was amazing. I saw a huge baked stuffed lobster go by me that also looked amazing. It was more expensive than I’m used to.

This was our second time coming here, and it was even better than the last time. The appetizers were AMAZING! We ordered their crab dip, steak bites and mussels in white wine sauce - everything was spectacular. The white wine sauce was delicious and we ordered extra bread to just dip it in and also use it for our lobster later on. For the main course we ordered the lobster roll which was fine I think it would have been better without the mayo or lesser Mayo, the lobster itself was great as my family thoroughly enjoyed it, the burger was fantastic too. Our server was attentive, funny and pleasant. I would definitely return for the mussels and crab dip! The view is always gorgeous which is a +. A wonderful experience as usual!

-Once again we drove the 40 minutes to have Amazing Sunday's Burger!!! Yes, they have amazing seafood with amazing presentations. A beautiful day, we started on the deck. When I was cold they changed our seating by their fireplace, without hesitation and always smiling. They are located on the Shinnecock Bay with the Ocean across the street, definitely amazing seafood here too!!! Adding more photos from our visit today. -This is a very nice restaurant, our waitress was great, food was great & the price was very reasonable for lunch in the Hamptons ($$ with drinks). We ate on the deck overlooking the fishing boats in the bay...a pictures lovers paradise. -It was our 32nd Anniversary; this was the perfect location for us...together with My Only Love, a camera, scenic views and perfectly cooked food made it a perfect day for Us. We would go back in a minute!!! Thank you for a great time!!! Joyce S. Back again for our 38th Anniversary, I needed to add photos. .l Love this restaurant!!! The food is always Amazing!!!! With an amazing location to eat overlooking the Great South Bay!!! A Little Piece of Heaven in the Hamptons. Joyce S