Milk Jar Cookies

I highly recommend stopping for here for a lil treat, either before or after your museum adventure in the area! The location is super accessible and has an inviting atmosphere. I found street parking with ease, but it might have been the rain keeping the crowds away when I visited. The staff is not only friendly but also very patient and well-informed. Now, about the cookies – I couldn't resist the classic chocolate chip, and it was predictably divine. But I decided to be adventurous and try their banana split cookie after reading some glowing reviews. Guess what? I'm a convert to that one too! Here's a fun detail – they even have cookies for our four-legged friends, which I thought was adorable. Definitely swing by, and don't forget to order a glass of milk – you'll want it! (Unless, of course, you're lactose intolerant.)

My wife received their cookies as a gift and we were really enjoyed. So we decided to visit their place. It’s pretty random location and I don’t think they have parking lot. We parked on the street. They do have cute interior inside the store. We went here on Sunday after lunch time. No customers at all. It was super quiet. We only saw togo customers. Ended up we got two boxes of half dozen cookies, one for us one for friends. Overall we liked their cookies because not super sweet. And also we really like their gift box packaging. Price also wasn’t that expensive. So me and my wife decided to get some cookies gift box for this year holidays. Highly recommended!

I was in the area and this wonderful hidden gem popped up on my Yelp app. I was excited to have some dessert after a nice lunch. I locked the location in my GSP and headed there. This storefront is beautiful and welcoming. Street Parking is available (Metered) As soon as I walked inside, the aromas surrounding my hostiles overtook me senses and I screamed inside with happiness! I was greeted with a smile and everyone was helpful. There were so many choices to chose from, I did something different this time and gave up control with allowing them to choose 1/2 dozen cookies for me. They have everything you can think of. Shirts Baking Cookbook Party favors Ice cream Take and Bake cookie dough Edible Cookie Dough Tea Coffee Hot Chocolate Cookies (Vegan, Gluten-free options available) Doggy Cookies for the fur babies Shelf life for the cookies are amazing and they come with great instructions to reheat etc.. Dine in options available Great Natural lighting Support this small business

It's yummy big time & gluten-free to boot. The recommendation lived up to all the hype about these cookies. For Christmas, I ordered a dozen mixed with the infamous Banana Spilt, Butterscotch, and Oatmeal. They come packed so fabulous in style along with not one cookie was crushed, they were all in pristine condition. Now flavor-wise, I can see why the Banana Split is popular as once you taste it you can't put it down. If you follow the instructions they come out just like out of the oven. Soft, and gooey with Pecan, Chocolate Chips, Banana, and Strawberry. The flavor is Spot on just like a Banana Split. Next, the Butterscotch was filled with Butterscotch flavor and soft along with gooey. The Oatmeal Chocolate Chip cookie was delicious the Oatmeal was soft and the melted Chocolate Chip oozed as you break the soft cookie. Microwave instructions are off, as I only needed to warm them up for 15-20 seconds. Keep an eye on them so they don't overcook and get hard. Each cookie comes individually wrapped, Big Shout Out to Courtney these cookies are da bomb.

Half dozen / chocolate chip, chocolate pecan caramel, banana split, mint chocolate, salted butterscotch- 5 🌟 x 6 I love cookies but for whatever reason I don't think to buy them often from specialty stores like Milk Jar Cookies or from bakeries. I am ashamed to admit I get my cookie fix at the grocery store. But not this time! Milk Jar Cookies are amazing! One detail I really appreciated was that they all have a uniform size and shape and they are also a large, very satisfying cookie. I brought them home and followed the recommendation to heat them up in the oven. I regret not trying them with milk (I never keep milk at home). Another element I really appreciated was how seriously they tale their covid precautions. They have an elaborate sidewalk setup that they clearly have to set up each day. Great spot if you have a cookie fix.

I got the cookies delivered to my house to surprise my wife for her birthday. She loved them and so did I. Delicious cookies. Every type was 5/5 (chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, oatmeal chocolate chip, sugar). They taste really good on the second and third day, too, if you care for them according to the instructions. The cookies are large (thick) and quite moist. No dry Chips Ahoy here. Peanut butter chocolate: 4/5 cookies and cream and cookie dough ice cream: 3/5 cookies in photo: chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin

Quaint cookie and ice cream shop with very friendly staff. Came here after dinner on a Friday night with a friend, and we were glad to have done so. You order and pay at the counter before grabbing a seat. There’s various flavors of cookies and although they all looked appealing, we went with a classic chocolate chip cookie. It was dense and generous with the chocolate chips. It was on the chewier side and my friend ordered some milk to go alongside it. We also got a scoop of the Cookie Monster ice cream on the side which the cashier let me sample beforehand. It had cookie dough and Oreos mixed into blue ice cream and I thought it wasn’t too sweet. They have ice cream sandwiches available as well that you can customize. The girl working was very friendly and smiley. The other worker also proactively filled the water dispenser (located next to the hallway where the bathroom is) after hearing me say that it was out of water. They play old-timey music and it’s a cozy atmosphere with cute decor. Overall a comfy place to hang and eat some cookies!