Old School Ny Pizza

I live in NE Ohio, 6ish hour away, and when anyone asks me my favorite pizza joint, it’s this place. I’ve had your pizza only twice, but it really did make an impression on me. I’m actually looking forward to coming back and having a couple slices. I’m happy to see the continued positivity for this local pizza shop. So good!

Hands down, best New York style pizza outside of New York that I had. It reminds me of NYC after taking a bite. I wish there’s one closer to me in Indy. This will be my go to pizza place from now on when I visit Louisville. The white sauce with tomato and spinach is a must! Stop reading now and order a pizza!

I visited Kentucky this weekend to visit my family and I wanted pizza but nothing that we had back home in St. Louis. I chose this place over many and believe me when I tell you me, my brother and my granddaughters approved. Everyone was so nice and friendly and the all meat pizza was 🔥 as we say in St. Louis when something is good. My next visit to KY this is the place my family will have lunch. Happy to have had a good experience.

This place is fire af the guy who took my order super friendly and the slices are cheap and the place is nice thr sauce is very flavorful and they heat the slices in the oven I took one bite and couldn't stop eating the pizzas aren't that expensive to plus the slices they have are most of their pizzas they serve so you can buy a slice and try it wish I came to this place a while ago

Their pizza? Legendary. I'm talking about crust so crispy, it could rival the sound of a touchdown at a football game. The taste? Well, it's the kind that makes you close your eyes and momentarily transport yourself to the heart of New York City. Each bite was like taking a stroll through Little Italy, with flavors that danced a perfect tango on my taste buds. But let's talk about the undercarriage, because that's where the magic happens, my friends. The crust was cooked to absolute perfection, with just the right balance of chewiness and crispiness. It had that golden-brown color that could make even the sun jealous. And let's not forget about the char marks, those beautiful blackened spots that added a whole new level of flavor to the pizza party in my mouth. Not only does Old School NY Pizza crush it when it comes to taste and texture, but the whole experience feels like a slice of nostalgia. From the cozy atmosphere to the friendly staff, it's like stepping into a Brooklyn pizza joint minus the long flight and traffic. So whether you're a bona fide pizza aficionado or just someone who appreciates a damn good slice, make your way to Old School NY Pizza in Louisville. This place is a hidden gem that deserves to be shouted from the rooftops. Trust me, once you sink your teeth into one of their mouthwatering pizzas, you'll never want to go back to your ordinary, run-of-the-mill slices. Old School NY Pizza, you guys are crushing it!

I flew into Louisville and went straight to work. After not eating all day, I ordered a pizza and salad. Easy online ordering. As a travel nurse, I've had NY pizza and this pizza was similar. Salad was fine, however, I ordered the cheeseburger pizza which comes with Romano cheese. I have to say, I hate Romano cheese--too sharp for my taste. Unfortunately, although I ordered it without it, they forgot to omit it. I wanted to love the pizza especially since I was starving but I couldn't. I did eat a few pieces and could appreciate the crust, the texture and with the right toppings, I'm sure it's quite wonderful. Regardless of my experience, I will give it another try next time I'm in Louisville. Staff was great, parking was easy. Food was ready when I arrived. Oh, I also had a brownie--it was delicious.