Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Was there today at 1 PM and there were four people ahead of me. We were in and out so fast because the guy making the sandwiches knew exactly what he was doing. I did not catch his name but he had tattoos on both forearms, and he was the best I have ever seen at his job. If his boss is reading this, the man deserves a raise, and a promotion. He should be running every store you have I was at the location at stony Brook next-door to wild eggs.

Before "The Rona" this Potbelly location was on a pretty regular Sunday lunch rotation for us. We've been there probably a dozen or so times and when Covid hit...well...this location (like so many others) took a big hit. Now that we're finally on the other side we're trying to get it back in our rotation again. The thing is, the hours are pretty inconsistent. For a while they were open on Sunday...then they weren't...now they're open, like, 10-3 seven days a week...unless they aren't. I understand that getting staffed back up is a challenge. Other than staffing, this location has usually been pretty great. The Wreck in an amazing mess of a sandwich that always hits my hunger spot. My wife likes the Loaded Baked Potato Soup. The store has never not been clean when we've visited, then again we tend to get there shortly after opening on when we do. The décor is decidedly J-Town with image of sports and sports players on the walls along with some sports-related posters around the place. I 100% endorse that the trash bins comprise of the trash side and the recycle side. During warmer months there's a garage door arrangement that can be opened for that are inclined to eat outside. On our most recent visit the store has been very nicely decorated for Christmas, with a tree and the tables have a festive runner and table-top decorations. VERY nice touch! I'm feeling good about this Potbelly again and hope things improve for them.

I would add a picture but I ate the salad too quick. I ordered the farmhouse salad added avocado (removed the cucumber it was still on it but I just picked it off) it was great. They didn’t skimp on the meats that were included like most places do. Well worth it for the price I will for sure be back.