Petrillo's Pizza

Monday I ate a Steak and Cheese from here and while biting into it, I bit a carpenter screw! Yes a carpenter screw I couldn't believe my eyes! I could've swallowed that! I'm sorry but that's not ok! The person I spoke to on the phone offered the money back and another free sandwich, but seriously I was NOT eating there again. They came back to give the money back but it wasn't the full amount and they also had the nerve to say "well at lease you didn't put a bad review on Yelp"! Seriously? What about me, the customer who ordered from you? Terrible! Please you guys are going to have to do better. I could've died!

I remember when Petrillo's first opened in Madison across from my father-in-laws restaurant the Clam Castle. They had the best pizza I ever had & still do. Thank God it never bothered Art when we'd go over there after work and eat. To this day, my sons & I still order from them at least once or twice a week and will continue to.

I used to love Petrillo's I swore by them, telling my friends that they have the best pizza around. Unfortunately, they didn't like it. I told them that can't be right. Not Petrillo's, but the last two times have left me very disappointed. I am now going to look for a new pizza place to eat. Tonight was the last straw..they take the order, but when I receive it it's not what I ordered. Like tonight..it was light sauce..they were heavy on the sauce, and as for the other one it was extra cheese and there was regular amount of cheese on it. The crust was all wrong as it was way too thin. I like a thicker crust. The last time the crust was all uneven. Really thick in some parts and really thin in others. Either they have new employees or they changed hands and not told anyone. That's how different it's been the last couple of times.

The garlic, pepper and onion pizza we had on Monday was the best we ever had, anywhere. Thin crispy crust, but just thick enough that it doesn't collapse when eating. And fresh, delicious toppings. Our dog is the only one not happy with Peteillo's- we usually give her the crust at the ned of eating a slice, but this crust is too good to not finish ourselve