Pizza Nostra

The pizza was absolutely unreal, and is most likely the best pizza I have ever had. It was nice and light and you can really taste the fresh ingredients they used. I drove from London to try the pizza and it was 100% worth it. The guys making the pizza were awesome and really showed an interest in their customers. They were mentioning that they will be offering frozen pizzas that can be shipped.. so I'll order a few once they are available and will 100% stop by again next time I'm in the city.

Placed the order over the phone for a 14’ Cheese pizza, very friendly voice took my order. Order was ready within 15 minutes. Parked infront of the restaurant and got my order. Friendly staff. Pizza was crispy and saucy. Definitely recommend creamy garlic sauce along with that. Will definitely visit then again.

I have now been here twice in 2 days. First time we ordered the Marco Special and was blown away by the quality of the pizza. The sauce, pepperoni and crust were all delicious. The creamy garlic sauce was garlicky but not over powering. Next day we go the Peapack and again, delicious but this time we tried the hot Italian oil and it was just enough spiciness for me. Would galdy recommend the pizza here, all the pizzas

Pizza Nostra is top notch!! Since the pandemic I would crave pizza similar to a New York slice! Discovering this place now doesn’t have me rushing to NY so soon. It’s nice, simple and with such great flavours. I usually eat my pizza with dipping sauce, but the pizza here needs to be eaten just as it is! Soo good!! We try to go every week because it is that GOOD!! We always eat it right away straight from the oven! If there’s available chairs outside we have a seat and eat it otherwise we will sit in the car to enjoy it. We usually order the margherita pizza or the pepperoni and cheese.