La Fine At Montauk Manor

Overall, a good bite for myself the family. Drinks are pretty strong (not a terrible thing) Appetizers were tasty (the crispy mozzarella was to die for), the sauteed Brussels sprouts were a good choice as well. On to the mains, the hilltop burger was good, although it was slightly undercooked (asked for well, it came back medium well), the penne a la vodka was cooked nicely with chunks of parmesan (loved it). Our waitress was terrific and was genuinely helpful but was sadly overbooked (she was there by herself).

We really enjoyed dining here. Atmosphere could use some attention. We liked the casual environment but it felt a bit like a college dining room trying to be cool with the garage doors and painted floor. Great food! We enjoyed the brussels sprouts side as an appetizer and the fried cheese. FOS broth was good but there needs to be more cheese on the top (just the little bit of bread in the center had cheese...definitelythe wrong type of bowl for serving). Penne Vodka was perfect and loved the addition of the asparagus. My husband enjoyed his burger. Drinks came out quickly and were good and strong! Our waitress was awesome! And she took care of all the tables on her own!! Kudos to her lovely service with a smile!! If the decor was updated a bit, and a few more options in the $17-$25 bracket added, I feel like this place could be pretty packed on the weekends!

My birthday dinner last night was a pork oasis buco and amazing desserts…Just as special as my visit to Montauk a year ago. Colleen will take care of you! 11 months ago: I had dinner, but they also have breakfast and lunch, and you have choices of rooms and ambiance. The moment you drive up to Montauk Manor expect something extraordinary. Don’t miss the scallops!

This place was awesome! Great food. Stand out was the octopus and the mushroom appetizers. I had the burger and it was not overcooked with plenty of toppings. Perfect location too. Nice sunset. This is high on a hill over looking the bay. The grounds really add to its unique location. Perfect with kids as they have a lot of manicured lawns to run around on while you eat.