Nicky's Coal Fired

I came here the other night for pizza and wine and I was not disappointed! The kale caesar salad is a great portion and was really refreshing. The pizza was perfectly cooked and had a fantastic crust. The house white wine was also very good and I like that you can get different carafe sizes. I will be back!

My husband and I had our surprise wedding at Nicky’s and it was the most memorable night of our lives! Tony, Caroline and the entire staff was so accommodating, thorough, helpful and amazing! The food and service was unparalleled and we go back as often as we can to enjoy the atmosphere, food and amazing service! I know i’m biased because i got married here but it really is the best restaurant in Nashville!

The food is DELICIOUS! Customer service is excellent. Run don’t walk, goooo. Order their meatballs. The only reason for 4 vs 5 stars: It’s a little confusing your first time going because it’s counter service. The sign helps some, but it’s still a little vague. Pick what you want, to to the REGISTER and order and pay for your food like a deli, the counter with all the menus is not where you order. We stood there for a hot minute before figuring that out. Then find a seat and they will bring you your food, we sat on their patio. Also, if you want to get more drinks or food after your initial order you have to pay again, every time.

My husband and I had our wedding reception dinner at Nicky's and it was WONDERFUL! We rented the entire restaurant out for a cocktail hour and dinner and it was perfect. The food was amazing, the space is incredibly beautiful, and the staff went above and beyond to accommodate. Special thanks to Katie for working with me leading up and day of to make the event so special. Couldn't recommend Nicky's enough for your special event!

Not the best pizza that I’ve ever had but decent. The kale salads was a bit of a mess. It just felt like the salad was a bag of kale dumped on a plate. It was not very flavorful. The place does get busy. Plenty of parking on the street. Try Jeni’s ice cream which is a short walk from the joint.