Petee's Pie Company

The apple and chocolate pies are the best sellers. We got both. Look at the menu before you go so you don’t get held up on choices. No lines when we went and outdoor seating. The apple pie is the champion, you can taste the fresh ingredients. The chocolate was like a rich chocolate brownie in a pie crust.

Petee's Pie Company is a must-visit spot for anyone looking for delicious, homemade pies. I've tried the banana cream, the Hudson Valley apple crumb, and the brown butter honey pecan pies. I LOVE cream pies so the banana cream pie is my favorite of the three. The Hudson Valley apple crumb has a lovely, buttery crumb on top that's flakey and sweet. The pecan pie is also delicious but a bit on the sweet end. All of these pair so well with coffee that it can be enjoyed for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and an afternoon snack. Their crust is extremely buttery and flakey and is perfectly sweet and savory at the same time with a hint of nuttiness. They're not exaggerating when they say they're "the best pie in NYC."

Delicious pies, bad customer service. (wrong pie!) Petee’s pies are delicious- not many people would disagree with that. The apple pie is a classic and HEAVENLY! However, I bought a pie only to come home and find out they have me the wrong pie. I was stuck with a $35 pear pie that serves 8, except that’s not what I wanted. But, I encourage you to get some to go and have it with some vanilla ice cream at home. I’ll be back, but I’ll stick to slices rather than risk getting stuck with a lot of the wrong thing again.

3/22/22: The two stand out things I've had here are the black currant streusel (very interesting sour taste in the fruit combined with a sweet crumb) and the classic NY cheesecake (great cheese texture with perfect crust), both 4.5 stars. Also had the key lime meringue, brown butter honey pecan, salty chocolate chess, and the Hudson Valley apple crumb which are pretty good but not stand out. Removing one star because prices are too high.