May Kelly's Cottage Restaurant And Pub

This place blew my mind on Irish food. Never had it before and I am forever changed on it! If you come here get the May’s Potato Pancakes, it was the most amazing experience I’ve ever had with food. 10/10 experience and I will definitely come back again! Edit: If you do not get the homemade cheesecake you are absolutely missing out, by far the most amazing one I’ve ever had! A bit sweet but the flavor and texture is worth it. Pictured below, we couldn’t help but dive into it before taking a picture!

This restaurant is an interesting gem. We were vacationing with friends and stumbled upon this place. Food is amazing and made from scratch! Everything we all had was delicious! The blueberry lemon bread pudding was out of this world for dessert. Our server, Nona, was wonderful! She was so friendly, funny, and gave great recommendations. The restaurant is kitschy and full of interesting things to look at. It is definitely worth a visit!

Went here with a party of 4 on a Friday night, we were greeted and seated promptly by a friendly young lady. Our server "Nona" was very friendly and attentive as well as very knowledgeable about the menu, she made several recommendations before we placed our meal. All of the meals looked delicious, I ended up getting the Pastrami sandwich and fries, it was indeed delicious. I don't ordinarily get desert, but after our servers recommendation for the Blueberry Lemon Bread Pudding, I ordered it. It is homemade and super tasty, I highly suggest trying it. The food was so good that we ended up back there 2 days later. I will absolutely be back the next time we're in N Conway.

Homey & quaint come to mind with warm hospitality from servers & a kitchen who seem to work fast. Portions are ample, so keep that in mind unless you're starving! I enjoyed the Taste of Ireland as my entree since it's a classic triple. ☘️ Split a dessert like the homemade blueberry lemon bread pudding with a scoop of vanilla ice cream - yum!😋

Chose this restaurant as it had the highest reviews for a North Conway restaurant and deservedly so. 3 zones to dine in, the pub, the dining area, and outside. Quite the menu of appetizers, sandwiches and dinners, so it was hard to decide on what to order! Pretty good drink menu as well. Love the cozy interior and ambiance of the place! Very attentive staff, excellent food and a very cool pub atmosphere. This will become a regular dining stop for us when in North Conway !

One of the best Irish Pubs! The trio sampler of Beef Stew, Shepard Pie, and Chicken Pot Pie is a must try. The beef stew and chicken pot pie pots are filled with chunks of meat and veggies, and topped with a biscuit. The Shepard's pie is made with a flavorful mixture of lamb and carrots and topped with oven browned mashed potatoes. This dish is sold as an appetizer but is large and very filling. The coconut margarita was a tasty & perfect blend of alcohol with toasted coconut around the rim of the glass; and the homemade sangria was delicious. Each drink was topped with fresh edible flowers.

What a great surprise on the way Just pulled over to check the map and saw this place. It looked nice from the outside and decided to give it a chance One of us had a gluten free restrictions and it had a great choice and solution. Even a dedicated menu All the food was tasty, fresh, the waitress was super kind and the view,... We sat outside, with a river view and the Ecco lake mountain If u r in the area, come over

We got the fish and chips, corned beef sandwich, the taste of Ireland. The food was good but they have a strict no outside food or water policy. They confiscated our plastic water bottles chasing us into the restaurant. Maybe they can make the policy more relaxed. Overall a good place for lunch, very heavy