Pizza Pub

Ordered online with a 30min pickup. 45wings crispy with a couple different sauces. Arrived 25min after ordering. Staff was friendly and had me on my way quickly. The only reason for any stars. Wings are far from crispy but still seemed over cooked somehow. Very gooey and chewy. “Hot” flavor was basically just butter and Franks. Everything sauce was ok but still very gooey. Boss Sauce was good but only recommend as a dipping. These wings are also very very small. Kids really thought we were having quail 🤣. Not sure what breed of chicken they are but they are also very veiny with deep purple and black areas inside. This review is of the wings only and we will never order them again. Can only hope the pizza would be better.

Ye Olde Pizza Pub in Oneida, NY is Awesome Awesome. The young staff up front were all very polite and helpful. The menu when you walk in is clear and nice looking. We were able to pick our own seats which was cool. The dinning area is very clean, same with the bathrooms. We ordered salads and riggies for dinner. The salad bar is very clean and definitely full with all you need. The self serve drink machine is cool because you can get whatever drink you would like. We sat to eat our salads and our riggies came out maybe 5 minutes later. Wow that was quick hahaha. The riggie sauce was great and not spicy at all. The noodles were cooked perfectly and the dish was hot when it arrived, definitely a plus. The garlic bread was a nice touch that I didn't expect. It was soft with a little crisp which is how I enjoy it. The waitress came twice and didn't hover which I like lol once we were done we had no problem paying or leaving the parking lot. It was very smooth and the trip totalled 45 minutes. Perfect! Thank You Ye Olde Pizza Pub, we enjoyed our dinner very much.

I have never had a more disappointing meal In my life. I ordered 20 wings and garlic cheese bread for a quick meal after a long trip. This meal not only cost me a ridiculous 35.00 but the wings were smaller than my pinky and the bread was cold , greasy and not evenly covered with cheese. I have never had comparable wings at any of the local establishments. This is the second time my family has been disappointed and we will be taking our business elsewhere.

The entire experience was awkward, the lady upfront seems to lack the understanding of how front end works. I don’t think they have a full ready to go set up in regards to how customers move in and out. We left after feeling it was too chaotic to have the patience to figure out their set up on our own and watching idle workers. Sad experience.

Overall, I enjoy eating at the Ye Olde Pizza Pub in Sherrill. The pizza is excellent, and the salad bar is nice (fresh ingredients)! I've ordered the Riggies, Pasta Primavera, and Chicken Broccoli Alfredo...all excellent!! However, what is not as good, are the wings! They are usually small, and they're breaded!! The sauce is good, but a bit small. But...other than the wings, I definitely recommend the Ye Olde Pizza Pub.

Have not been to the Ye Olde Pizza Pub in forever and this was the first time at the new location. We ordered takeout and it was perfect. The pizza was delicious just like we remembered. The antipasto was by far one of the best takeout salads we’ve had. Next time we will try dinning in. They still have those long tables and movies playing!