Cold Stone Creamery

I’d like to start off by saying I’m not one to complain about restaurants or even leave bad reviews, I’m currently a manager in retail & have worked as a manager in food service for some years now so I completely get it. However, this had have been among one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had. Honestly if I could put a 0 of 5 stars I would. I went to this Coldstone creamery yesterday with my younger sister, all we had ordered was a salted caramel apple & then their surrender to strawberry sundae creation. The surrender to strawberry sundae is supposed to be their strawberry ice cream with chunks of strawberry, bits of cake and whipped cream. Firstly, I had paid with a gift card & was given no receipt to keep track of the balance on the card… no big deal considering I can use the website. After being rung out I noticed that they literally just took plain strawberry ice cream & put it in a cup…. NOT what I had ordered. Right after they rung us out they immediately ran to the back to chat & hide. I know this because I went back up for them to remake it waiting there patiently not saying anything & they peeked around the corner & then ran further in the back to hide upon seeing me waiting… luckily there was another lady that actually was out there rather than hiding in the back. I walked up to her & politely asked her if she can remake my order because maybe there was a miscommunication. This was then met with a snooty attitude & her “remaking” what was supposed to be my sundae was her taking my ice cream out of the same cup, mixing a few strawberries into it & then putting it back in the cup. Complete & utter disappointment, drove 20+ minutes for this behavior & plain strawberry ice cream I could’ve easily gotten at my local Kroger for much less. Needless to say, I did not even finish the ice cream & threw a good majority of it away as I was so upset.

Love love love their ice cream!! I always get the same thing.. peanut butter cup perfection, but I substitute the chocolate ice cream for sweet cream! Yummmm! I typically get the "gotta have it" size cup. And the only reason I gave four stars instead of five, is because sometimes they don't fill the cup as much as they have advertised. ColdStone has amazing tasting ice cream and I'm a happy, frequent customer!! If you've never been here, you MUST try it! Prices are slightly high but once you taste the ice cream, it will justify the price. Oh, and if you tip the employees, they all sing a song! Cute! You can also sample the ice cream flavors if you can't choose which one you want. This location is always clean and is well stocked with not only ice cream, but other treats such as: caramel apples, ice cream, frosted dog treats, buckeyes, and the list goes on! It's all in a beautiful display at the counter.

This is my favorite Cold Stone location. It has a wide selection of chocolates from truffles, to big peanut, almond, and cashew clusters. Peanut butter cups that they call buckets because they're much bigger than the famous brand. Besides the amazing selection of ice cream combos, my other favorite thing there are the candied apples. My particular favorite being the buckeye apple. Dipped in caramel then covered in a shell of chocolate and peanut butter with a likeness of their inspiration. It's so incredibly tasty. So yeah, 10/10 would recommend for ice cream and treats.

Wish they offered more dairy free options other than only the pink lemonade sorbet, however the staff were more than willing to check ingredients of the mix ins for me to make sure they were appropriate and acceptable to my vegan diet. When they weren’t sure, they even read off the ingredients to me. Not only did they check ingredients for me, but they were also extremely friendly and helpful. Employees worked together and I was glad when I asked about ingredients instead of saying “I don’t know”, they were more than willing to check for me.