Pj Lobster House

THE PJ LOBSTER HOUSE, PORT JEFFERSON NY 👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍 For our 60 Wedding Anniversary, I wanted to take my honey to a good rated seafood restaurant, that we have not been to before. We live in the RVC area, my honey always loved walking around and visiting the shops in Port Jefferson as well as grabbing a bite to eat there too. When looking at different places to eat, This restaurant I found is called, The PJ Lobster House, in Port Jefferson. It had a great menu of dishes we love to eat, their prices looked very fair in this age of high prices, and the restaurant had pretty good Google reviews to boot too! This restaurant has booth and table seating, a bar area, and a fresh fish market all in the same building. Through the years we have been to Port Jefferson many times, but never knew this restaurant existed. It's address is 134 Main Street, but it's NOT on the main road, it in the back behind other buildings, in fact, for the first time ever, my GPS sent me to a wrong place a mile away from where the restaurant really is? I was lucky to run into a postman, who told me exactly where this restaurant was. We got to the restaurant at 1:30pm, there were some people having lunch, and some having drinks at the bar, but not crowded at all, that was fine with us. Our waitress was Sandy, She was great, she didn't rush us, was very friendly and helpful too. We told Sandy that first we were going to order a few appetizers then after that, if we were still hungry we would order something else. Sandy said that's not a problem. So to start off I ordered their New England Clam Chowder. It was fresh tasting, buttery and was loaded with clams, just delicious! Then a dozen large sized Little Neck Clams(top necks) on the half shell. They were very fresh, crispy iced cold, with a snap when bit into them, topped with fresh squeezed lemon juice, a dab of cocktail sauce, and of course some fresh ground horseradish, they were excellent! Next we had their Coconut Shrimp with mango sauce on the side for dipping. They were cooked perfectly, we've never had better! Next we had their whole baked clams oreganta, they too were on the money, simply delicious! Now here comes a bucket of fresh mussels cooked in white wine and garlic, yum, yum, yum, is all I can say. We ended our appetizers with a cold octopus salad, which consisted of fresh greens, sliced cooked octopus, olives, cherry tomatoes sprinkled in a light oil. Also just delicious too! Sandy asked will there be anything else or are you full? I ordered their Crab cake sandwich that comes with french fries, cold slaw, tomato and lettuce and a topping sauce. My honey ordered their hot Lobster roll with butter and sweet potato fries and cold slaw. Both were excellent choices all freshly made for us. We were both about to bust from eating so much delicious food, but I asked to see their dessert menu. I ordered their raspberry sorbet with chocolate syrup and whipped cream, Wow! My wife ordered their creme brulee, another Wow! Delicious! I can imagine this restaurant must be very busy on the weekends, we will come back for sure, but we again will go during the week for an early lunch as we did today. We enjoyed all the food ordered and Sandy our waitress was perfect at her job, she made us feel very welcome and at home even for first timers at this restaurant. This restaurant is really a hidden gem, in Port Jefferson! A very nice place to go and have a wonderful meal with friends and family!

We were waited on by Sandy who was hospitable and welcoming. We ordered the firecracker calamari, lobster roll with a side of fries and cole slaw and the Surf & Turf special. Absolutely delicious!! I would return again if ever I was in the area. *sidenote: daily metered parking is available in the back lot of the restaurant at $1/hour or you can elect to park elsewhere for free.

Visited Pj's Lobster House in the heart of downtown Port Jefferson and was completely captivated! The atmosphere is adorably charming, capturing the essence of the town perfectly. The service was impeccable — genuine, friendly, and attentive. Now, let's talk about the food: the Alaskan King crab legs were a mouthwatering delight, and the lobster was cooked to sheer perfection. A five-star dining experience that shouldn't be missed!

Nice day in Pt Jeff. Not humid ( finally) . Asked for outdoor seating. Food was amazing. Killed 3 loaves(round) of the bread, served warm..always a hit. Lobster rolls, cold and hot, Mediterranean salad, crabcakes and of course the raw Oysters. Oysters were just perfect. Cold, sweet, tender,and perfectly clean. Our bad for sitting outside when yellow jacks most active.

Excellent all around. We sat at the bar, and they were slammed with business. Everyone was nice even though it was very busy. Sandy at the bar was attentive, friendly, and right on top of everything, even when it was crazy busy. Food was very good and the atmosphere was just right. Thanks for a great night!

Hi me and my 2 sisters went to your PJ Lobster House yesterday, Wednesday. We decided to go out to Port Jefferson to look around. I haven't been out there for about 2 years now. We notice the little indoor mall and the sign outside with your restaurant name on it. We went in and ordered our food, all of our meals were good. I'm sorry I don't have pictures to show of our food. I just ordered a cheese burger with/fries and coleslaw, it was good. One of my sis had the sampler seafood and said it tasted good. My other sis ordered fried Shrimps, mashed potatoes, and salmon cakes and her meal tasted good also. Thank you, for the good meal and sorry I forgot the young lady that served us. We will be back soon 😊💕😋.