The Pie Hole

I absolutely love this business. The owner is great and the pies are amazing. I highly recommend ordering a pie now and when the pandemic is over, stop by for a slice or two. She changes up the variety all the time, but you can almost always find apple, cherry, chocolate chess, and many more. My family loves the fruit pies, the chocolate silk and coconut cream, but we have tried at least ten of her different kinds and they were all excellent.

I contacted The Pie Hole for help preparing desserts for a group surprise birthday party for my wife. The owner just was fantastic talking through what I was trying to do, options, and so on. We ended up going with a family recipe dessert, and the owner suggested individual portion mason jars, which worked fantastically. The owner then scaled the recipe on her own time to figure out the portions needed across our order. It just came out terrifically. I almost never am completely unrestrained in my appreciation, but here The Pie Hole just knocked this custom dessert catering out of the park - So grateful that I got their help. Thank you!

Don't bother going here unless you are either a soccer mom or very rich! A chicken pot pie FROZEN costs $40. It is not even the size of a Costco pie. Unless they are singing to the chickens 🐔 not sure why anyone would pay this price. So why did I go here you might ask? I had a 25$ gift card. Which didn't buy anything to this place! I had to add another $15 to buy a pie. And you have to normally order in advance

Best sweet pies in metro Atlanta. The peanut butter with chocolate crumble crust is just decadent. The chicken pot pie is a bit on the sweet side and not as creamy as the one by Southern Baked Pie, but is filled with nice meaty chunks of chicken, carrots, beans, and potato. Only the operating hours prevent us from coming here all the time. If you have a regular 9-5 job you'll have to take time off or go early on Saturdays to get a pie as they're not open on Sundays.

A religious experience Savory or sweet, The Pie Hole has it. Their chicken pot pie will make you say "Marie Calendar who?". It's truly epic. The crust is perfect. This is the crust on the pies your grandmother made at Christmas. Yes, it's that good, sorry grandma. Now let's talk sweet. From perfect crust to exquisite filling, every pie is something sent from heaven. The apple pie measures almost 6 inches in the center. That's right, HALF A FOOT OF PIE! And the chess pies, chocolate and lemon. The word trancendent almost captures it, but not quite. If you're within 50 miles of Roswell Georgia and you don't make the trip to the Pie Hole on Canton Street then it's painfully obvious that you hate kittens, bunnies, and everything good in this world.

I love pot pie but cannot really find a good one - this has been an issue in every state I've lived in. Most places don't have a good crust or don't have enough veggies in the pie or tastes 'fake'. So I wanted to try this pie place to see. I live a bit a way so I wasn't familiar with it at all. It is literally just a little pie shack on a little dirt road in the built up part of downtown Roswell. The owner, I think, is the only employee as I recognized her voice on the phone and was the only person in the shack. She was stressed and not very friendly (at least on the phone) but it was mother's day weekend so I understand. She was friendly at the pickup window but was doing everything off of a notebook piece of paper. The great - the pot pie was amazing. Huge, tasty crust, well seasoned, tons of chicken and veggies that were real and fresh. The not so good - the website looks like it was from the 90's with not much info on it - just the possible pie list, contact info, and no prices. The place needs to update/streamline their ordering process and website. The price of the pie was $34 which was really high. I got it because I drove all the way up there and wanted to try it but I wish I knew that before hand. I would totally eat it again but I'm not sure if I would pay that much for it again. $25 I think is my limit for a pot pie.

SUPER RUDE STAFF… didn’t even bother going there as the lady who picked up the phone seemed to be doing me a huge favor by answering my questions over the phone. I am surprised cafes or shops with such rude and terrible customer service are allowed to exist and entertain paying customers… super upset with her behavior….