Goodly Cookies

Sweetest, gooiest, most heavenly cookie out there. And that's saying something for the suddenly saturated cookie market! I was introduced to these cookies at a Utah Jazz game. The only downside is that their only location in Salt Lake City is downtown. Totally worth the drive, but open up a south valley location!

I ended up to this store for a Yelp Elite event and was pleasantly surprised! I had gone to other cookie shops before, but those cookies were always too sweet for me to enjoy them fully. For example, the cookie itself had enough sugar in them but then they top it off with more sugary frosting… This store itself was cute with a very clean and modern look. They even have their own (kindda gated) parking spots. The worker inside was very friendly and more than willing to help me out with my 4 cookies. With their help, I ordered their most popular cookies: Chocolate PB Love, White Chocolate Raspberry Delight, Big Cinnajon, & Brookie. When I brought them home, they were all a HUGE hit!! Each of them had great quality with just the right amount of sweetness & chewiness. The Chocolate PB Love had the perfect balance between cookie and peanut butter. The Big Cinnajon was also delicious with its cinnamon flavor. Cinnamon can be very overpowering but it had just the perfect amount in it. The White Chocolate Raspberry Delight was an unexpectedly delicious one. At first we were little hesitant about it but the slight tanginess brought out even more flavor with the white chocolate chunks!! Finally, the Brookie was the super star of all of the cookies! The mix of brownie and cookie was wonderfully & masterfully matched!! Sometimes the change in texture can be jarring but they pulled it off like a professional :P Overall, all the cookies were amazingly delicious with just the right amount of sweetness in them. No wonder they are the “Official cookie for the Utah Jazz” :D

This review was made possible by none other than my good friend Shay (our fearless Yelp leader!) as she got some today and I had to give her my order so I can try these! These are probably the best cookies I've ever tasted here in Utah (so far!). First off, I commend them for doing their chocolate chip cookies RIGHT. So many cookie places here in Utah county (one of them rhymes with "bumble") use milk chocolate chips in their chocolate chip cookies, which adds too much sweetness to the cookie. I mean c'mon, everyone knows that the batter already has sufficient sugar used in there, adding milk chocolate chips to the (already sweet) batter results in too much sweetness (can you say diabetes?!) I'm an INSTANT fan when cookie shops use semi-sweet chocolate chips in their chocolate chip cookies, for the semi-sweet chocolate chips BALANCES the sweetness of the dough, which makes the BEST chocolate chip cookies as a result. Bravo Goodly, BRAVO. You do chocolate chip cookies JUSTICE. Their white chocolate raspberry is really delicious too! You can definitely taste the raspberry, but you can taste the white chocolate a bit more. It leans toward the sweeter side (than tart). My ultimate favorite cookie of theirs is none other than their lemon!! Can you say the "best lemon cookie" I've ever tasted? The perfect balance of tart and sweetness, and with every bite, you want more, more, and MORE. As my friend, Shay stated, "I couldn't stop eating them!". I concur....I concur. I will be back for these lemon cookies!! I'm hoping that this flavor is a permanent flavor of theirs!!

I love that they are open late and their cookies are great. I've stopped in a few times now, and tried quite a few of the flavors offered. They were all great, and will definitely drop by again. The cookies come warm, and most of the flavors are really well balanced and not pure sugar, which makes them refreshing.

Tried out Goodly Cookies for the first time and was not disappointed! This shop was open for pick up and delivery until 1AM, which worked perfectly with my late-night sugar craving ☺️. We got the: Goodly General Chocolate Chip - original Chocolate chip cookie Chocolate PB Love- chocolate cookie with melted peanut butter chips White Chocolate Raspberry Delight- white chocolate chips and Raspberry pieces The Pumpkin Mallow- pumpkin chocolate chip cookies with a bruleed marshmallow on top. All were so delicious and I can't wait to go back to try more flavors!

DELICIOUSSSSSS!!! I personally think that this place was a tad bit better than Chip and Crumbl. I've had both of those several times and Goodly topped the charts in my head by comparison with the simple, yet timeless staple Chocolate Chip cookie. Theirs was PERFECT crispy with the insides being soft, warm and not too gooey. With Chip and Crumbl, I still like those places but they tend to be a tad more gooey than I like. They offer milk here, too and have a water station as well. Really cute place! Small parking lot on the side for like ..6 cars or less. Probably need to park on the street. A box of 4 is $13, a single cookie is $3.50. I got a box of chocolate chip, PB and chocolate, cookies and dream and double chocolate walnut. The fav was PB and chocolate with such a perfect balance of the two! Go try it!

Fabulous! This used to be just a cookie delivery service but has recently opened this amazing storefront which now also serves ice cream sandwiches. These cookies are AMAZING. I have been to most of the other comparable cookie places in salt lake & Utah county (I know. I'm excessive). This is by far the best. The cookies have a nice shell without being too crispy and are soft, dense and flavorful on the inside without being doughy. Some of their competitors cookies are overly sweet which is a bit of a turn off for me. These are the perfect balance. Tried the classic chocolate chip as all as their chocolate peanut butter one. Both were amazing. The classic one is probably favorite. I wanted to get a pic of my ice cream sandwich to share but in my excitement to eat it, failed. Ice cream is rich and thick--classic slow turned parlor style ice cream. They use one cookie and half it with a good serving of ice cream. I got one to share with my husband and 2 year old son. Perfect size for sharing. Also- GREAT friendly customer service. All in all I LOVE goodly and am so glad they have opened a storefront. Bring these to any birthday or gathering and you'll for sure be a hero.

In my opinion, best non-gourmet cookies in Utah. I say non-gourmet because that is a cookie that you can eat a lot of, that being a good thing. Gourmet consists of Ruby snap, which is amazing, but cannot be compared to Goodly. Large, consistent, flavorful, and satisfying cookies that stand a full staircase above the competition. Order on chow now for even greater ease and get those cookies faster to satisfy those intense cravings. I came from bountiful to get these bad boys. Late night cravings have never been so thoroughly coddled by the delicious flavors Goodly is slinging.