Supreme

Have really enjoyed Supreme for the year and half we’ve lived in the neighborhood. However the last couple times there has been a huge drop off in quality. We live a few blocks away so I was right on time at the 5pm pick up time. I ordered caesar salad and the Big Banger pie. I got home literally 5 minutes after picking it up, and the pizza was not only cold, but was a soggy wet mess. Toppings slid right off, and dough was still somewhat uncooked. I then opened the salad to see that there were 2 croutons and the lettuce was wilted. We still ate the salad, and had to heat the pizza in the oven at home. The reason I’m giving 2 stars is because the flavor of the food is still there. However the overall product has left me disappointed twice now and we’ll probably take Supreme out of our pizza rotation.

This place gets 5 stars simply for the fact they offer pizza until 2am or whatever 7 days a week. That being said, I have experienced variance in terms of their pie quality, but my last few visits have been consistent. For example, being given an extra slice because the pies were old/burnt. Supreme has the best ranch I've ever had. I didn't even know until I was graced with one unasked on a recent slice. Supreme also introduced me to Detroit style pizza.

Here's my original review which I called "EXPERIENCE #1" from like a few weeks ago: "Best dough in Seattle, period. Better than Proletariat and all the rest by a country mile. Seriously, this place is making top notch dough on their thin crust pies. Absolutely outstanding. Five stars." Now, for the pizza I got yesterday. EXPERIENCE #2: Just a few weeks later, decidedly middle of the road, bordering on meh. Wow! What a change from my first experience. Major consistency issue here, from what I've seen. This time, the crust was NOT the best, and to boot, toppings were underwhelming. I paid for extra cheese, and got barely detectable cheese. Plus, I paid $44 for one pie and this was so not worth it. Yikes - what happened?! This leaves me puzzled, seriously. How can a place's pizza go from awesome to underwhelming so fast!? I have to ask, where is the good pizza in West Seattle hiding? Sorry Supreme, VERY disappointed! Three stars (feeling generous) - average to four (but closer to three, seriously). NEXT DAY: Who doesn't love leftover pizza? Answer, everybody, if it's this pizza. Adding photos of second experience, day after. The pizza was sausage, onion, peppers and EXTRA cheese. Look at this, this is 3/8 of a $44 pie. I count ten strand pieces of onion, nine green pepper slices, BARELY any cheese, and ten tiny pieces of sausage. And I'm disappointed to say that I paid $12 extra for the extra (supposedly) cheese, onion, pepper and sausage. I can't figure out how this place went from a really good pie just a couple weeks ago to this garbage. Staff issues? I don't know, but this was truly bad pizza. OK, dropping this to 2 stars, but I am done wuth Supreme. Sorry, but I would be irresponsible to ever recommend this to anyone. I've made pizzas at home for decades and I really hate to be negative, but man. This is really disappointing. Sorry Supreme, but it's true to say, I am SUPREMELY disappointed.

Every Friday, I’ll visit my girlfriend in West Seattle and every Friday, I’ll order a pepperoni pie here (occasionally with extra parm). Every Friday, I’ll wander over to pick up my pie and every Friday, the kitchen will be swamped and run 10 minutes behind. Every Friday, I’ll have a beer while I wait and since I’m not really a beer drinker, I’ll waddle back with my pie slightly tipsy. Every Friday, I get to enjoy the best damn pie in Seattle. My girl is moving so I won’t be able to swing by with the same frequency, but hot damn do yourself a favor and order a pizza here.