Fratelli’s Eatery

I wanted to like it. I really did. There's an old adage that you never have a second chance at a first impression. It applies well to my first time here. I heard through the neighborhood app community that Fratelli's was a decent addition to the neighborhood. My wife and I ordered 2 pizzas to try them out and it did not go well. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom and a vegetable combo with fresh mozzarella. It's on their menu. When I got there after a LONG wait, they asked what I had ordered. I told them and they said 1 of them had been made wrong. Now I have to wait. They gave me a slice of carrot cake as a way of saying oops. The pizzas are not very good. If you've had Sophia's you know what I mean. The vegetable pizza did not have fresh mozzarella and the crust was all soggy with tomato juice. And it was cold. The pepperoni pizza had about 3 inches of crust all around it and everything else in the center of the pizza- poorly made unless you like a lot of bread. I get it, mistakes happen. But I didn't feel good about returning anytime soon. Such a shame. I love local businesses. The carrot cake was the highlight of the misadventure.

I was very disappointed in the food, I called and ordered a small/personal size thin crust Margarita pizza and a small garden salad. They stretched the crust so far that when they cooked it the center wasn't cooked, just dough. It came in a large box and I knew before I tried to eat it, it wasn't going to be any good. I paid almost $23 for this, ate 1 slice and dumped it. Yes, the sauce was sweet.

Finally a local pizza shop that consistently provides amazing pizza, and great food! Chicken bacon ranch and Buffalo Chicken pizzas are my go to's and do not disappoint! All of the employees are friendly and extremely nice! Thanks guys and gals for always delivering above my expectations and having my pie ready for pick-up in less than 20 minutes!