Crust

Crust is one of those pizzerias that has a very strong niche, and that is the grandma pie. A very crispy, saucy, and fresh taste completely outweighs their traditional round pie in quality and taste. Very good, and honestly underrated. Please note that this is not a knock at Crust, but I would come here specifically for the grandma pie. A well done square, I mean, look at my photo. They carry many unique specialty grandma-style pies that are fantastic. Prices are reasonable. Crust hits the mark for yet another eye-catching, mouthwatering pie in the Staten Island area.

This place takes pizza to a whole new level. They have a label for each pie behind the counter which states when the pizza has been made and when they take it off counter... have never seen that anywhere. Pizza was very fresh and filling, mouthwatering and just simply delicious. Would recommend and very worth it for the price.

First and last time eating here my food took so long I didn’t know if I should be glad or not at least I knew it was fresh right so after waiting an hr for 3 personal small personal pies( -1* ) I get home which is literally 4 minutes away I go to eat the pizza and the crust is rock hard idk it it was cuz it was a personal pie or if they was going to the thin crispy crust but it was super hard (-1*) then the taste smh wasn’t nasty but I didn’t taste like good ole fashion pizza and my mozzarella stick was mad Lightskin yea let’s just say I wasn’t pleased at all

For a place serving sub-par pizza on Staten Island where there are tons of better pizzerias, you'd think they'd at least be pleasant, quick, or cheap. They're not. Try to order a personal pizza and they will tell you they are out of "personal pizza dough." Can you not simply cut regular dough smaller? Is it that difficult? They call back thirty minutes after an order to tell you what they don't have instead of letting you know as you order. I've had this happen to me for several orders. The staff is rude and demands understanding when a simple order is two hours late. In two hours, I could have gone to five better pizzerias. I've even had them tell me that I should pay full price for a full pizza that they brought by accident instead of the personal I ordered. They simply don't know how to run a restaurant and blame customers for not accepting what they're given instead of what they ordered. My most recent order was my last straw. Do yourself a favor and get better pizza at a place where they can actually fill orders and not whine about how hard it is for them to run Crummy Pizzeria.