Pusateri's Chicago Pizza

The atmosphere here is hard to beat! The only thing better than the pizza was the service! Our waitress was so sweet and funny! Thanks for the good food and great conversation! The pizza was 🤌 perfect, crust was flaky and crisp, perfectly cooked, loaded with cheese and so many toppings! You definitely get your moneys worth here! Love that they employ vets too!

Living in Chicagoland for 30 years, I was skeptical but they are LEGIT! The pizza was amazing. The sauce was perfect, the cornmeal dough was wonderful, and crumbled sausage was seasoned perfectly! Even the beef sandwich took us back “home”. Add the 312 brew and I felt like I should have been freezing near the lake instead of relaxing in Stuart.

Our first time here and I’m a NY/NJ girl but my husband is from Illinois. I will have to say the salad and pizza was delicious. I have a new found respect for Chicago pizza now!(but I’ll never tell him!) Sherry our server Even brought us out an appetizer because it was a busy night and was taking longer than expected!! Definitely a place you’ll want to stop and eat. Kudos to all the cooks!

I've never had Chicago style pizza before and was excited to try it. I was told that Pusateri's had very good pizza. It started out very positive. I was greeted immediately and allowed to choose my table. The menu looked great. Nice, clean and quaint dining room. Convenient location. Fast service. Friendly and helpful staff. Great selection of toppings. Unfortunately, this is when it took a turn. A beautiful looking, golden brown and well done thin crust pizza was brought to the table. It was cut into little square slices which made it easy to eat. I was super disappointed after taking that first bite and expecting a delicious pie. Although the toppings and sauce were excellent, the crust tasted like cardboard. Reminded me of a frozen pizza crust. I hate giving bad reviews, but the crust is really important in what makes a great pie. Perhaps the dough was not prepped correctly this day. All I know is that I'm a big pizza fanatic and tried pizza from NYC to Napoli. I left feeling let down. C+

I have been intending to try this place for over ten years. (I don't eat out very much.) I discovered there is a nice covered patio in the back of the restaurant and seating for 14 more inside. I enjoyed the thin crust sausage pizza and some of my dining companions had the Italian beef sandwich. Everyone raved about the meals. There is a lot more on the menu I would like to explore. This is not just a pizza place. My group had excellent service. I am not going to wait 10 more years to go again.