Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Sometimes things don't go as planned. I placed an order earlier in the day but was late arriving for my chosen pick up time. My order was lost. (This was not necessarily a bad thing.) The manager apologized and quickly filled my order. The team was very professional and courteous. I left with a hot pizza and I had a great experience! Great team effort! Thanks!!

I hate to even give this review. We been going to to Anthony's coal fire pizza for 8yrs. We'Ve been to the one in Clifton multiple times . once in Edison and multiple times in wayne. We LOVE their chicken wing and we always get a half pepperoni half sausage and broccoli rabe pizza. Tonight was the first time we have order well before covid-19 and was very upset to see they didn't have sausage and broccoli rabe on the menu. So we replaced it with black olives which was horrible. We tried the "NEW" wings. they were ok came with NO sauce. disappointed this time around with Anthony's for take out. please bring the sausage and broccoli rabe back on the menu. Only favorite of the meal tonight was the chicken wings

Service was fast and friendly. Cocktails were good. Meatballs were excellent with the oven baked chicken wings smothered in onions produced nice flavor. Pizza was excellent and had plenty of toppings. Thin crust was soft on inside and charred and crunchy on the outside. Definately recommend and will return.

I understand that these are difficult times, but I am truly disappointed in my take-out experience with Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza of Wayne. I have had wonderful take-out services with other restaurants and expected the same with them, since I frequently dined there prior to social distancing. Last Sunday, I ordered a special family bundle with an extra Italian family sized salad. They placed it in the back of my car, said goodbye, and thank you. When I arrived home, I realized that the salad was missing and called the restaurant. The manager apologized for the mistake, but he asked that I come at another time to pick it up instead of just crediting me the eleven dollars. We called this evening to pick up the salad. They told us that it would be ready. My son waited over half an hour with multiple servers coming to clarify his pick up order, which means multiple interactions with people. After waiting in the parking lot for over forty five minutes (for a salad, mind you) another server asked him to clarify the order once again. I was livid. There was no reason for this! Being a rewards member, I'm truly disappointed that this restaurant did not just choose to credit my account instead. Very disappointed!