Caffe Amici

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. Highly disappointed. I had been here before, bragged about it to my husband and friends only to be embarrassed when we came to eat here. Service was horribly awful, did not get a refill once. Took forever to get the waiters attention to actually order, then a long time for food to come out, and once the food was out… everything was freezing cold. We didn’t even eat it due to how nasty it was. They forgot our side salads, never got checked on. Sat another 45 minutes only for us to have to ask for our check, never came back. Had to ask three other people to get our check. I ended up having to speak to the manager due to the terrible service and the state of our waiter. I am only giving two stars due to my first experience that was good.

Second time going since we came to Columbus and unfortunately that’s only because every time we go we spend almost up to $200 on food. But it’s absolutely worth every penny! Delicious authentic Italian cuisine, great choices for wine and cocktails, and the staff is amazing. We were fortunate enough to get Noel as our service again, he was our server the first time. He really knows how to take care of you and make sure you are having a great time! If we are lucky enough to go one more time before we move, I am requesting him again! Highly recommended from an Italian raised husband!

Had a Lunch portion of Lasagna which left something to be desired. I've always enjoyed the food but this time it seemed to be all cheese, to much in fact, covering the very small piece of Lasagna, not enough, about a 2.5 inch square. Served in a serving dish 4 times it's size. I realize it's the luncheon size but I was disappointed.