Pizza Casbah

Giving one star because I can’t give less. Long time customer and I will not be coming back. Management has changed and you can definitely tell. Pizza is always under cooked. If you ask for any type of toppings they give you the bare minimum. Staff is not nice what so ever and what’s even worse is the owner wasn’t any nicer. I am not one to complain because I do not like confrontation and understand what it’s like to work in a restaurant but they have messed up multiple times with no compensation. When I brought up the issue I was told I was lying and asked why I even come back this being said by the owner. Horrible management and low quality food.

In my opinion the best pizza place in Fort Collins. I am a fan of East Coast (New York, New Jersey) style pizza. And this hits the spot perfrctly. Food is super reasonably priced delivery always comes in a reasonable time even when they are busy. Always where I order from when I want pizza. And their staff is so friendly on the phone when I place an order. Lots of options to customize the pizza to your liking which is great.

Big fan of this pizza, as well as the folks working there. My pizza was a little charred and they offered to remake it and gave me the slightly burnt one. I paid it forward and gave it to a nice group of folks walking by. Good sauce, great crust, just the right chew on the cheese and good pepperonis. I'll be back often, I suspect.

On vacation and wanted to try local instead of a chain. Took almost 2hrs for delivery 1.3 miles away and pizza was cold and over cooked. The crust was too hard to even eat on the outer edges. You could tell the ingredients were quality and the flavor was good though. I suspect it would have been a lot better experience if we dined in the restaurant. Would like to give more stars but it is what it is. Garlic knots were solid.

I’ve been supporting Pizza Casbah for the past 18 months, and it’s been great. Last night, I ordered a pizza that took over an hour to deliver. When it arrived, it was stone cold and over cooked. Reheating it made it inedible. I called to speak to a manager who talked over me and did not take the matter seriously. I stated that I wanted a refund. I was told that I would not be refunded and would be given a store credit. I’ve received nothing and Pizza Casbah has lost a loyal customer. Can’t wait for The Corner Slice to open in Old Town.