Mahalo New York Bakery

For our mother's 50th surprise birthday, my sister and I were struggling to find a nice bakery. We stumbled upon Mahalo Bakery and read their story. My mother also from Guyana and also spent a month in Hawaii and loved it. We wanted to bring light fruitful flavors since our mother isn't a fan of cakes but loves pastries. The owner was very nice and had us taste test with cupcakes and we loved the Mango cupcake, which worked because our mom LOVES mangos. When we brought the cake to the party, everyone complimented the presentation and when we finally shared it out, they wouldn't stop raving about it. Most importantly, our mom loved it who once again isn't a fan of cake. Everyone was asking for the name of the bakery, I wished we took more business cards. I definitely recommend everyone to stop in and simply try a cupcake. We will be back with more orders. (The best photo of the night before it was demolished lol)

Just ordered from here today. I ordered the mango cupcake and the whipped cheese cake. The mango cupcake was delicious moist and came with mango frosting and mango filling inside. This was the first time I tasted their cupcake. I must say I really enjoyed it really delicious. The whip cheesecake the individual size It’s a no bake cheesecake and it’s the guava flavor. Now I didn’t know what to really expect but to me this was more like a pudding or custard like dessert. It did not really give me the cheesecake kinda feel or taste. Now the guava that topped it and tasted really nice together. I will definitely go and try their other bake goods.

We have been ordering from Mahalo for a while! Their cakes and cupcakes are so moist and delicious. The favors are also so divine. We stop in here from time to time to try some of their new treats and the owners are really great at adding new things to their menu. I would highly suggest their cakes and cupcakes for events! Your guests will thank you!

This review is long overdue. Sue and the team at Mahalo are truly amazing at what they do. I've been a customer for a couple of years, ordering cakes for multiple occasions, and every time I am completely blown away by the final product. You can tell Sue takes pride in her craft by her attention to detail, and the fact that she only uses fresh ingredients. She's constantly able to take our vision and turn it into an amazing piece. I highly recommend Mahalo to anyone for any occasion - birthdays, weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, gradation - and for cake and cupcakes!