Carlo's Pizza

The service tonight was bad. Food was really good. Was told 20 min for pickup. I arrived 25 min later, to find out order is not ready. Not a huge deal, except that 8 other people were waiting for orders all standing around with one lone man tending the register and making pies. Long story shorter....waited 20 more minutes for them to finish pie, forget to make a wrap, and barely warm up two slices. The older guy was clearly out of his depth with the workload of making pies and manning the register. It was terrible weather so maybe he was down a person or two, who knows. It's dark, lights barely work, needs another oven and a helper. But, the white pie with broccoli and crushed garlic was really delicious. On the small side but fair priced. Wanted to give a lone star (ha) as I waited and drove off but the food got it up two stars. I'll give them another shot on a better weather day.

Fantastic food and great service. I would suggest anyone driving by or anyone who needs catering doe consider this pizzeria. I have eaten pizza all over NJ but this one has something magical about it. My wife had a dinner and it was like eating a meal from a fine dining establishment without the sticker price. Do yourself a favor and give this guy a shot, you wont be disappointed. Tony B.

I’m not sure what happened to this pizzeria but it went down hill these past few years..... it used to be my favorite....... now it’s simply horrible..... the pizza sos it watered down tomatoes, very acidic and the cheese I was chewing like gum....... Not enough variety when you want pizza by the slice........