P.j. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Lancaster

Amanda was awesome great service,it was a full bar she made sure everyone had what they wanted...she told awesome very nice and always had a smile on her face ..if I could give her many more stars I would...PJ are lucky to have an awesome bartender as Amanda def telling my friends coming back again . And a shout out to Kianna she totally awesome an asset to your company always had a drink in all your customers hand bar was totally full I give her infinity stars pleasure

My husband and I came last evening for the first time. He lovesd his orange crush drink. The fried pickles were awesome and he loved his wings and fries (small portions) and to go pork BBQ sandwich. I got the summer strawberry and avocado salad and it was good but barely any feta, strawberries, chicken or avocado on it. The waitress did bring me extra avocado slices but this would have been a great salad if it had more than 80% lettuce in it, especially for $14.99. Summer salads are usually filled with these things. The salted Carmel cookie was out of this world. We will definitely be back.

Second time I've been here. Nice place to eat at a reasonable price. Wings were not as good as I expected. A little disappointed with our waitress this time. Maybe she was just having a bad day which happens. We believe she forgot to put in our wing order. They didn't come out until after everyone else was already done eating. And she forgot to grab us a refill on our drink after we asked. She said she would get it but ended up doing other things instead. The place was pretty empty so it wasn't that she was super busy. We will probably be back again to try it out some more.

Came for my dad's birthday dinner and was not disappointed. Great atmosphere, diverse menu and good food. Our server was over worked but some how able to serve us perfectly. Got us drinks as they went empty, didn't forget any of our food, she was doing a bunch of other tables and even saw her seat people from the hostess station. I hope you give her a raise and give her kudos...her name was Rose. Thank you for great birthday for our dad and a great experience.

A solid choice if you’re looking for a sports bar, especially if you’re a Philly sports fan. Service is usually pretty good even when they have a packed house. There is a good variety of beers on tap and mixed drinks. All of the food is pretty affordable. I don’t know what the breading is on the wings, but I love the texture. They are also the perfect size.

The food was delicious and reasonably priced. The atmosphere, definitely a sports bar. It was pleasant though. We waited at least ten minutes for a server to visit our table. Our daughter approached the check-in area and told them, then we had someone come to our table. I understand post Covid but still. This isn't a slam to anyone in particular, I'm just saying that it's nice to have *someone* make an appearance in a timely manner. Anyway, our server was courteous and we did enjoy our food. I would consider returning. Update: Thank you for your response! It's good that you are addressing issue. I don't want to see anyone in particular getting in any trouble as I think that it was just a general issue.

Really enjoyed this place. I sat at the bar. Bartender was super friendly with good drink suggestions. I got the wings with their signature hot honey sauce. The wings were a little too breaded compared to how I like them but still good. The sauce had a good flavor but not too spicy. I will definitely go back.