Fat Cat Pizza

Very good thin crust pizza. Crispy with quality toppings. Solid salads. The best I've tried so far is their wings. Absolutely perfect! They don't put anything on them, just fry them naked like a proper Buffalo wing. Their process produces moist, extremely Crispy wings. You'll eat more than you think so order extra.

The food was really good, but not nearly good enough to justify the ridiculously high prices, especially given the tiny portions (the "extra large" being the same size to an inch smaller than a large at most places, burgers MAYBE a quarter-pound). Service (if it could be called that) wasn't that great and the hour-long wait for the food (not all of which was close to not) seemed ridiculous given that it didn't seem to be very busy. Nick's tastes basically the same at around 1/3 the cost, 1/3 the wait, better portions, and generally twice the service.

They were very short on staff which made the wait time for food longer. They even had a sign in the door about a longer wait time. I understand that. The waitress was very polite and did the best that she could. I ordered the lasagna with salad and breadstick. It was outstanding, but I received my lasagna when everyone else was almost done with their food.

It's a mixed bag with this place! It used to be our favorite pizza hands down, but over the last few years their service has dropped tremendously and is quite horrible most of the time. Their pizza is hit and miss now...when it's not over cooked and everything is good, it's our favorite pizza, but more times than not there is something wrong. That inconsistency and terrible service has us normally looking for other pizza places and coming back to Fat Cat only occasionally....usually disappointed too :(

We all love the sweet taste of Fat Cat Pizza! My adult boys all want Fat Cats when they come back home to Lancaster! Other favorites include deep fried mushrooms, pickle spears and the salads are always fresh! Actually I don't think there are ANY bad menu items at all?! Ample parking, clean restaurant and good service since they first opened! BTW if you haven't tried their baked lazagna, you are missing out!! It is truly baked to perfection!!

Owners are HORRIBLY rude and mean to employees and customers. .I do NOT EVER recommend going here, they do not deserve your money at all. Pizza Cottage, Pizza Crossing, Donatos, Dominos, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars, Sugar Bears, and Cristy’s are all waaaayyyyyy better options and are all within 10 minutes. I have also heard stories from 3 people who have worked there about roaches in the kitchen and cheese and other ingredients being dropped on the floor and then being scooped up and put on pizzas.