The Yelling Goat

We went to The Yelling Goat on a Wednesday and it was surprisingly busy. Nice atmosphere, but the space is a little tight. We sat at the bar and bought drinks. The bartender gave us menus to order food but ignored us for the next 20 minutes. I was pretty frustrated with him. So my wife and I decided to sit at a table. The waitress was excellent who waited on us and memorized our order. My wife had the grilled romaine salad with added chicken and she probably would have given it a good review but the bacon on top of it had too much bacon grease on it, which was probably just a mistake. I had the BBQ chicken fingers, which I really liked alot. We ordered a Hawaiian pizza to go which I'm bringing home for my kids. My grade is 3 out of 5 stars based on average overall service and average food.

Having been there twice, I have to say... I am thoroughly impressed. The freshness of the ingredients is paramount to the quality of the taste. Personally, I ordered the steak salad (pictured), and being someone who is extremely picky about the food I consume, this restaurant ranks in my Top 5 of WNY area eateries. I was brought here by my godparents a month ago, and decided to return with my parents. All of us enjoyed our meals and raved about it to our extended family, at a gathering afterward. Our server was attentive and made sure all of us had our drinks topped off. If I were to pick a place to eat every night, this would be one of those places. Just incredible. Thank you!

This is a fantastic place!!! So much to choose from!!! There’s hamburgers, pizza, wings, sandwiches and entrees!!! I tried the beef on weck, and it was out of this world!!! So delicious!! The best I’ve ever tasted!!! ❤️ My husband had the wings, and they were so good!! Our waitress, Shelly, was very nice and attentive. She brought my mother a beer sample to try!! So kind and thoughtful!!! If you are in Lancaster, NY, you should stop at the Yelling Goat!! You won’t be disappointed!!!❤️❤️❤️

This was my first time coming here and I had heard a lot of good things going in. The menu was full of a lot of good and varied options for all ages. I ordered the chicken parm and it was one of the best I've ever had. The chicken was well seasoned and flavorful. The pasta was cook just right and the sauce was addictive. We also ordered the fresh mozzarella which was just as good and also covered in the same sauce. The overall atmosphere was delightful. I was beyond satisfied with my experience and hope to go back soon.

What a place!!! The most fantastic food, staff, and of course wine.... They have something on the menu for the whole family. If you are anywhere near this place, stop what you are doing and go there. Update. This place just keeps getting better and better!!! As the weather breaks get to this place ASAP. The pizza is off the hook good! And I forgot if it’s snowing there is no place better to wait out the storm.

Took the little lady to the Yelling Goat last Sunday around 3 PM. Hostess sat us in no time. Drinks were ordered and arrived in a timely fashion. The wife ordered the corned beef on rye which she said was simply divine. I had the Bourbon chicken wings which were excellent. Our waitress was EXCEPTIONAL!!!Great place ! We will return....