Ingleside Village Pizza

Eclectic atmosphere. Very original. Friendly staff. Pizza was yum! Thin but thick enough and just the right amount of crunch. Dripping in grease if you get pepperoni which is how good pizza is! Large Caesar salad fed 2 of us. The knots were eh. It’s not oil it’s almost melted butter on the knots. If you go sloppy it’s a TON of butter, too much. That was the only negative I took away, the garlic knots. I wouldn’t order those again but I would def eat here again! Lots of good choices for pizza. Cute town with antique shops across the street.

So we were traveling from florida back home to Wisconsin and we decided we were hungry for pizza. I looked up pizza reviews in the area and i came across this place, i read my reviews talked to the husband and decided we would try it. Absolutely loved the place. Loved the decor! So much Elvis stuff! Staff was fantastic and nice! Food was out of this world! Had a dinner salad which was good, breadsticks, OMG! TO DIE FOR! We had the ultimate pizza, perfect crust, perfect sauce. The only issue we had is that we ordered it without Green olives ( which i seen the guy that took our order put it in and said it twice to us, no green olives) but we got green olives...so we picked them off and enjoyed the amazing pizza! Thank you for amazing good and a wonderful experience!

We stopped by on a Saturday night in search of some good pizza and we found great pizza. We started off with an order of breadsticks, which were covered in Parmesan cheese and butter with garlic. Just delicious! I ordered a slice of the White pizza just to try it out and that was flavorful, so much so that in hindsight I should have ordered a whole pizza. We had a pepperoni pizza and a cheese pizza and they did not disappoint. I loved how each bite had a little crisp to it which is what I like in my pies. Add in the drink station, where you can mix and match combinations of sweet tea and lemonade- just a great place to sit down and have some pizza! Great value too!

It’s all about the dough. I’ve been coming to IVP since I was a kid and they have consistently good pizza. White pizza is prob my fav, add bacon or sausage. I also am known to go into some unchartered territory with anchovies or pineapple and these folks embrace my order with full arms, delivering a pie of dreams. Delicious crust. Don’t forget your extra sloppy breadsticks.

My wife and I have been going for close to 10 year now to Ingleside Pizza and its honestly the best pizza around. We have been to Italy and has authentic fresh Italian pizza, and it does not even come close to being as good as Ingleside. Medium cheese and extra sloppy breasdsticks every time. I can't even choose a favorite part. The crust is perfect every time. The Sauce? The single best blend I've ever had. Cheese? Plenty to spare and fresh every time. The staff? Always friendly and helpful and the consistency of the staff over the years is clear proof that they care about what they do and they care for the staff. I can't think of a single negative thing about Ingleside. 20/10 would recommend every time.