Mcnulty's Tea & Coffee Co

It did not live up to it's reputation. I asked what roast was best for cold brew and bought their recommended roast. It cost almost twice as much as my usual coffee from Marie's at Arthur Avenue in the Bronx. For that money I expected a clearly superior brew; instead it was not as good as I am used to. I will give them another chance with a different roast prepared in a French Press.

This place is a gem. I love the setup of their store! Seeing all the jars of tea across the walls and island, and bags of coffee lining the room had a real old-school, but classic feel. One of the coolest tea and coffee suppliers anywhere. Super helpful and friendly staff. Their tea and coffee quality are top notch and there's a great variety of products here. Tourists and locals alike should come shop at McNulty's.

Step back in time and enjoy a straightforward yet adorably endearing tea/coffee buying experience. This is a multi-generation stop that, overall, seems unchanged by the passage of decades outside its windows. This is in the best way, as it’s an experience all its own. They have a massive selection of coffee and tea here, with many different flavors and hard to find options. You can buy it by the pound. For the coffee, it’s either whole beans or they’ll grind it to your specified fineness. Their coffees and teas are always delicious and they’re so kind in the shop.