Carmella's Plates & Pints

Very eclectic atmosphere. Dined upstairs in a private room. Seems to have been built into an old home in the South Side. Mostly everything I ate was delicious with appealing presentation ( steak was not cooked to my liking but that's ok). Bourbon selection is mind-blowingly vast and will require many trips to make a dent in the varieties. The stairs to the upstairs are very steep with a small tread so be very cautious. There is a public parking lot next door which was very convenient.

AMAZING ATMOSPHERE, delicious food, and vivacious libations! Date Night was upon us and we are extremely happy we chose Carmella’s Plates & Pints! This place has always been amazing with incredible service and the menu is always exquisite. Carmella and her staff are the nicest people and every dining experience there leaves us wanting to come back again very soon. Thank you Carmella, keep up the outstanding work, and congratulations on your 10 YEAR ANNIVERSARY!

I stopped in here while walking in openstreetspgh. I have never been here and this place blew me away. The bar and back seating area are amazing. Beautifully decorated, I was in awe. The staff was also super friendly. Everyone asked me how my day was, I couldn't have felt more welcome. And the egg and bacon sammie was just what I needed to give me energy to finish the walk. I can't wait to revisit this place soon.

Very nice family-owned restaurant with a very unique vibe. The walls are filled with historical images and memorabilia, which gives the vibe of a very cozy cabin. The food is excellent - we had the burrata salad as starter, and the wagyu burger and the scallop pasta as mains. You can bring your own wine (corkage fee is $15) but their drinks, and especially the cocktails, are very good too. I'd definitely recommend the Manhattan. The food menu gives suggestions for what wine pairings would go well with each meal. Will definitely come back again (been there for dinner but also the brunches are also great at Carmella's)