Paddy Cake Bakery

If you're looking for custom cakes at a really great price, Paddy Cake Bakery is the place for you! The cute, punny store name hints at the fun atmosphere. The store is very pink and the scent of baked goods hits you right as you walk in. As you walk in, you have cookies to your left, cakes to your right, and the counter straight ahead. My two favorite parts of this place are the price and the service. For a half sheet of cake with custom decorations, it came out to around $55, which is way cheaper than other bakeries. They're also incredibly friendly over the phone, and can take your cake order 2 days before! I will say, the half sheet of cake is a little dense and dry so it goes well it frosting, but I'm pretty picky about the frosting so it wasn't my favorite. But if you like frosting more then you would love this cake, and I actually like dense cakes so I enjoyed that part. Overall, if i needed another cake for an event, I would definitely order it from here!

Best all around bakery in Pittsburgh. Great value for price! Ive been to A LOT of Pittsburgh's bakeries, and many more out of state to measure by - Paddy's is "top notch" or some might say "upper crust" (ha! Get it?!) I bought about 15 items, and consumed them across 2.5 days (still have 3 items to go!) They were all the best of their type that Ive tried in Pittsburgh.... nutroll, poppyseed nutroll, danish, carrot cake, birthday cake, icing filled choc chop cookie sandwich, smores cookie, jammie cookie, long john donut... im looking forward to the almond cupcake and pumpkin roll. The ladies in the shop were super helpful, knowledgable, and patient, while we traversed the whole dispay case.

I go to this bakery every month but used to go multiple times a week. The staff are extremely nice to me and the prices are very reasonable as all of the treats are decently fresh. Every month they support a charitable cause. They don’t get as much business as the Starbucks next door takes a lot of it. This is a very nice little bakery and I would highly recommend coming here. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Five Stars!

as a stereotypical millennial, i hate to have to call a place but for paddy cake it's worth it!! their website is hard to navigate, but i don't care. ordered ahead for a small gathering and was so pleasantly surprised. strawberry shortcake was GORGEOUS! wrapped in plastic around the sides and boxed carefully so that i could unveil it at the party. it was a jaw-dropper, an absolute centerpiece. layers of cake, custard, and cream with fresh-tasting strawberries on top. fragrant and beautiful. i've frequented paddy cake before and reliably enjoyed their cookies, donuts, and treats but had never ordered anything larger before. will be relying on their amazing cake and amazing service from here on out -- cannot recommend enough! a neighborhood gem.

The three woman working the day I had went there were all super friendly and nice. It was the day before Easter and we stopped in from being at the hospital. It was so nice to grab fresh air and fresh bake goodies. There was so much to choose and pick from. The decor on the baked goods were super cute and I was obsessed with my dipped chocolate peep. The pineapple upside down cake was good even a few days later. I can’t wait to come back. This place is amazing, ten stars, price is fair and so good too. My husband and I will definitely be back and tell family & friends about this place.