Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Third time trying this place and this is the second time of the three we received a charred, burnt pizza. We were giving them a second chance but will never order here again. I understand this is coal-fire baked pizza and that there will be some variation in the crust. The first one we had from here was excellent. However, these last two are beyond coal-fired and are inedible due to the overwhelming burnt taste. Luckily we ordered through Door Dash and received a refund. Just a heads up for those who may be dissatisfied by this as we have been, especially for a $29 pizza.

I believed the hype and spent money on “dry rub” wings that are just the original wings cooked to rubbery death with a pile of spice just dumped on them in the takeout container. Dry Rub means you season them before they’re cooked, right? Not at Anthony’s apparently! Same with the Buffalo wings. I will never order wings from here again.

I'm giving this restaurant 5 stars because after several carry out orders during these trying times, from various restaurants, this by far is the best. The pizza was delicious and the salad was out of this world. Good for you guys for making carry out fantastic! You didn't even forget the extra salad dressing. We will be supporting your restaurant as often as we can. Thanks again!

Was shopping at Trader Joe's next door and needed a quick dinner. Ordered two 16" pizzas for take out - $40 + tax/tip. Crust was burnt, although maybe burnt pizza is a thing now? Sauce was really salty. Dough was not chewy. Pizza was cold after a 10 minute drive home. There are plenty of other local mom/pop places in the area where you will get a cheaper, better, non-burnt pizza. Pat's Pizza, Giordanos, heck even Grotto is better and cheaper. Look at the other reviews - there are months and months of similar comments, and they respond with some cut/paste corporate nonsense about how they will do better. Save your time and money, go elsewhere.

I called on Anthony's this past Thursday looking for a place for 50 people to eat on Saturday. The manager spoke to GM and called me back in 15 minutes to say they would take us. To say I was a little nervous to see how this evening would go was an understatement. However, the management and staff were nothing short of fantastic. We ended up with 60+ people. We needed extra chairs to which they found and found quickly. The wait staff were extremely kind, efficient and friendly. They took our orders in a very timely manner, the food was delivered quickly and efficiently. The food was delicious and cooked to perfection and delivered to all 60 of us as if we were a table of 4. The checkout process was equally as efficient. I just want to say thank you to everyone at Anthony's for making my 15th anniversary celebration a huge success. I highly recommend for a family of 4 or a large group. You won't be disappointed!!! 🌟🤩

After waiting an hour for our delivery, it arrived burnt and cold, this was my first time ordering from this establishment and it will be my last. I called them immediately and after speaking with 3 different people and having to explain my complaint I was offered a restaurant credit to which I flatly refused. Let's see how quickIy I get my full refund.

Nice staff. Great pizza hot out of the oven when you are dining inside. Crushed tomato sauce on traditional gives a wonderful flavor. Cauliflower pizza from their speciality pizza selection is delicious. Lemonade is okay. I would have preferred it to be a bit tarter. Coal oven pizza has a great crust.