The Whiskey

This place is an absolute gem! I happened to meet one of the bartenders outside on my way in and he welcomed me inside and got me seated. I believe Sam was the bartender I had and he was extremely knowledgeable about the whiskey they had and how they were made. I told him what I liked and was searching for and he was quick to find some options. He ended up finding a whiskey that happened to be the best darn whiskey I've ever had and I highly recommend it if you're there! Even though the place was completely packed, I never once felt like I was waiting on service or was rushed. Amazing group of staff and a great atmosphere. I highly recommend checking this place out and I will be back here again very soon!

All the staff are super knowledgeable about whiskey. Biggest selection of whiskey and scotch in the region. They are so nice and helpful and will help direct any palate. Chill atmosphere and Chase is super friendly and has amazing customer service. Accessible to both novice and experienced whiskey/scotch connoisseurs.

NOT IMPRESSED AT ALL!!! We have always heard great things about this place and finally got the chance to go in and see what all the hype was about and I can’t be more disappointed. I get that it’s a Saturday night and they were busy but to wait an hour just to get one glass of whiskey is ridiculous! Our waitress was such a dud, no personality at all and could care less about our table.They boast that they have over 1800 whiskeys to choose from and we were told that they were out of three of the five we wanted, not only that but it would take at least 30 minutes for them to come back and tell us that they were out of the whiskey that we ordered. I have no plan on ever coming back to this place and would rather buy my own whiskey then waste my time or money at this place again!

Honestly— a terrible, awful experience at the Whiskey. The door man was extremely rude. He accused me of being “too drunk” which was not true (I only had one drink before). I was not sloppy or slurring; just waiting in line to get my ID checked. I told him that he was in the wrong and he called the cops on me. There are a few other reviews on here similar to mine— written by women. Seems like this doorman has a pattern of being rude and aggressive toward women. Just a super disappointing experience. Met my partner here and unfortunately will never be coming back. Plenty of other great bars in Fort Collins to go to, this one just isn’t worth it. Bummer Whiskey… you need to do better.