Tiberio's Pizza

Tiberios use to be the best pizza place in Lancaster. Now that it has a new owner it is terrible. They said our pizza would be ready in an hour and a half when we got there to pick it up they hadn’t even started it. We were told it would be 20 min. More went back to pick it up the woman said she canceled our order. Very poor way to run a business.

This made me sad, this was my favorite, but sadly the stromboli that we purchased was worse than just bad. After cutting it up there were large parts that had no cheese, pepperoni, or mushrooms. After I pulled the top there was plenty of the toppings they were just in a single place. The sauce was still good and I bought some packaged crust from the store and used the toppings. Included is a photo of the clump of the pepperoni.

This is a Lancaster Legend!! The pizzaria has had a few different locations over the years but the quality has never deviated. We love the stromboli from here! It's all hand made fresh packed with meat and cheese. The sauce is sweet, they give you plenty of it. So if you're like me who likes a lot of sauce for the stromboli you'll be satisfied. I recommend there side salad with the in house Italian. Its creamy and delicious. This is by far the best pizzeria in town. Go get a slice or a stromboli you wont be sorry!

I loved Tiberio's when it was downtown, and I miss their full menu their fried zucchini was the best in town. They're still the best their pizza sauce is undeniable the best in town, like their pizza. My favorite dish is Chicken Parmesan, oh my goodness I could eat it everyday. not kidding!! The bread sticks are awesome (but not good the next day I've not figured out how to keep them great like they come) I always get a whole order not just 1 that comes with the meal that's not enough. They have more then Italian foods they also have the hamburger, fried bologna I think even fries and I've had their hamburgers and fries they're all really good.