Greek Star Bar & Grill

What was ordered -vs- what I got 🤔 There’s enough rice for a family of 4, the veggies are COMPLETELY dead, the filet was unevenly cooked so my rare/med rare was more med well. It did have a good flavor though. The rice has a little too much cloves. Stick with the Falafel’s, but get the tzatziki sauce (even though they’ll ask you a million times if you’re sure or “explain” what it is 🤣)

I dislike leaving a not 5 star review but I hope this helps in making changes. My husband and I went to eat there for lunch today. We had Greek food at a food truck a month or so ago and were really excited to try it again because the 1st experience was great with the food truck not this restaurant. With that being said, we stood in the lobby for quite some time and no one came to seat us so I proceed to go to the backwash room and ask if we should seat ourselves? We both ordered our food. Still very excited. I am not quite sure what the difference was between this restaurant and the food truck that we had a few months ago but it was not good at all. Our food was brought to us and that was the last communication that we had with our server the entire time . Not to ask us how the food was or to even offer us refill of a drink. My husband then got up and asked for the check so we could leave and I did not want to sit here for another 30 minutes because she never came back one time. I am absolutely not a needy person but the basic minimums were not even met. To me it was all around not great experience and I would not go back.

worst take out I've ever had.... I genuinely, and literally, wouldn't even feed this to my dogs... I'll admit, I didn't tip... But a tip is earned.. (This has happened on several occasions- I've been coming since ~2017, since pandemic has gone extremely downhill)... Given several chances since then, and it seems to only get worse and worse each time. should've taken photos but I threw my gyro out almost as soon as i opened it as you it was completely soaked and everything but the chicken was unedible, honestly... $18 for this... You couldn't pay me $18 to come back to this place to be honest.

I always liked Greek Star. The food is great. But today, i ordered online for carryout. I ordered two traditional gyros. I got home and ate one. It was delicious. So i grabbed the second one right away, and from the first bite, I felt like the food was contaminated with dust. It got worst with the second bite then I decided to spit out the whole bites. The way it was wrapped was different from the first one but I didn't suspect anything until I felt like it was dropped on the floor or something. Along with thst I tipped them twice because they included a promised tip in the total amount but when i got to the store they handed me a merchant receipt to sign and it had a blank tip line and without realizing the amount included tip, i tipped again

I’ve eaten here numerous times. When I first started coming the food was good. Good sizes and flavor (although it’s always over sauced leaving it a bit soggy). These last 3-4x I have went the food has been awful. I saw the other reviews and just assumed they had some bad days but it’s been consistently bad recently. Literally everything had no seasoning. I had a chicken gyro bowl and a regular gyro. The tatziki sauce was not good and had no flavor, the lamb tasted like it was boiled in water… it was just all around bad and the bowl was equally flavorless. I’m hoping they get back to how they used to be because the food is just gross now.

First time to Greek Star !!! I can’t believe I have missed this spot.. I had the lunch special gyro and the chicken shawarma and feta fries and baklava. Cooked to perfection what was supposed to be hot was and served in less then 10 min. Amazing happy hour drink specials starting at 3$ on a Tuesday .. and the service exceeds exceptional.. Fady was knowledgeable and guided me through the menu as I explained to him what I was thinking for a meal. He made the entire experience welcoming and fun! He was patient and enthusiastic in serving.. I could write so much more but I am beyond full of amazing food so to relax now. See ya soon Greek Star! 6/11/2021 Peter is the most artistic bartender and perfect host. This is my forever spot for food and beverages. Ordered chicken shawarma and lamb shawarma and spicy chicken and baklava and the most amazing feta fries , healthy portions and different drinks.. I am so over the moon about this place and hope you too can experience this amazing ness with date night or even kiddo night.. this hidden pickerington gem don’t let it go.. with the love of food